OntologySummit2007 Survey/ResponseAnalysis

Latest Version:http://ontolog.cim3.net/file/work/OntologySummit2007/survey/wip/ResponseAnalysis-issues-20070421.html
Date Issued:2007-04-21T17:07:21Z
Status:Work in progress
Description:OntologySummit2007 Survey/ResponseAnalysis Ontology issues

Ontology Issues

IssueAPAVBCBMBPCMDMEAEBFOGNIMINKBLCLRMDMLPTSASDSGSWTHTMTXW2XMCount
Education8 14 2   6 1  315  57 74254212
Demonstrate utility4  1   1 5    1 1  14 2  31 7
Development methods3 1  2  1     1 21  3 2223 26
De-mystifying and simplifying ontologies and ontological terminology3        2  1   1  13 4  22 5
Cooperation among different groups4  1     21     3  21 2  2214
Lack of common understanding of what is meant by an ontology1  1 1        1 21  2  111  4
Lack of expertise in ontology development2  1     1          2 21 21 3
Difficulty of converting legacy knowledge1               1      1    2
Gap between academics and industry   21               1 1  1  2
Lack of an upper ontology2  2 2          1  11 2111112
Resistance to disruption of the status quo11    1           11111   112
Achieving balance between expressivity and computational requirements1                  11 1     1
Clear identification of referents                1   1     111
Difficulty and effort required for producing high quality annotations1  1     11     1     1     1
Disagreements among experts1  1 1             1  1 1 1 1
Intractability of reasoning1  1     1         11  1 1  1
Lack of an open, well-maintained clearinghouse for ontologies and related products and services that are enabled by them1 1  1              1 1 1   1
Lack of motivation to create a standard1        1            1   1 1
Lack of ontologies for various domains         1          1 1     1
Lack of tools                    1 11 1  1
Reusability of ontologies   1                  1  1  1
Should not be left to the logic of the mathematicians1          1  1 1  11 1  11 1
Slow rate of adoption   1                  1     1
Tool incompatibilities1  1     1          1 1     1
Unification of data and exploitation the unified data1            1     11       1

Communities

AbbreviationCommunity
APApplications Development, Software Engineering and Information Model communities
AVAviation Information Services
BCBIM and CSI specifications
BMBiomedical communities
BPBusiness Process and Project Management Communities
CMConcept Map community
DMData Mining
EAEnterprise Architecture Communities
EBElectronic business
FOFormal ontology communities
GNGenomics
IMInformation management
INIndustry Research
KBKnowledge base user communities
LCLinguistic communities
LRLegacy Systems Reengineering communities
MDMetadata communities
MLMultilingual Architectures
PTProcess Technologies
SASystem Architecture communities
SDStandards Development communities
SGSGML
SWSemantic Web communities
THThesauri community
TMTopic Map community
TXTaxonomy communities
W2Web 2.0 communities
XMXML communities